Blu-Ray + CD Review: “Pretenders with Friends”

Pat FrancisAlbum Review, Blu-Ray Review, MusicLeave a Comment

 

Pretenders with Friends

If you were lucky enough to to attend the Pretenders with Friends concert at the Decades Rock Arena in Atlantic City, NJ on August 11, 2006 you probably had an spectacular time. Reliving that same concert via Blu-Ray and CD, unfortunately, not so great.

Pretenders: Sound Issues

pat francis review pretenders blu-rayLet’s start with the CD… the audio quality is poor at best and sounds like someone just took the audio from a VHS cassette. It doesn’t sound like any post production was done to the audio used for the video to make it sound like a real live offering. Throughout the album many of the songs fade out at the end and fade in at the beginning. This technique is of course fine on a studio album but on a LIVE recording it breaks up the flow of the concert listening experience.

Possibly a more egregious offense – there are two edits during the song “Precious.” There is nothing less rock’n’roll than bleeping out swear words – in this case, the words “Shit” and “Fuck”. Shame on you Cleopatra Records. No one underage is going to purchase a Pretenders LIVE album from 2006, so why not leave those words intact for your adult customers?

Pretenders with Friends, like Kings of Leon

It must be noted that Chrissie Hynde sounds fantastic. In fact, she sounds so great that all the other “friends” that join her on stage sound like American Idol rejects. First up is Garbage lead singer Shirley Manson. Manson has an amazing voice but on this recording she actually sounds nervous or intimidated to be sharing the stage with Hynde, and that comes through in a lack luster vocal performance. Next up are Kings Of Leon and Incubus. Both of their front men sound horrible singing their own songs and even worse when tackling the Pretenders tunes they are given.

Last and certainly least is Iggy Pop. Pop has never been known for his vocal chops and on this disc he is an absolute mess. The prospect of a Hynde/Pop duet on Iggy’s tune “Candy” filled me with excitement; that is, until I heard it. Pop is painfully out of tune, off-key or whatever you want to call it. Some may think that’s cool or punk or rock’n’roll but for me it was just embarrassing.

Pretenders with FriendsThe Blu-Ray option is a little better since Hynde and Pretenders are always great to watch and the video quality is top notch. The packaging is also great and includes a booklet, CD, the the Blu-Ray and DVD. All elements come housed in a four panel digi-pak fold out. The cost of the whole package is very inexpensive and completists or diehard Pretenders fans will definitely want to add this to their collection.

However, as stated above… “buyer beware,” as this is not what you might hope it would be.

review Pretenders with Friends

More PCB Music Coverage

Musical and amusing, Julian Velard is a hit in London
Ignatius Shea goes inside Ned Roberts: Outside My Mind
An evening of wine and storytelling with Dar Williams

(Visited 243 times, 3 visits today)
Pat FrancisBlu-Ray + CD Review: “Pretenders with Friends”